|
|
CHIEF MACHINIST'S MATE EDWIN FREDERICK MATHYS was born on November 5, 1903 to Frederick and Sarah Mathys in Washington. His father had emigrated from Switzerland and eventually had enlisted in the United States Army, where he served for twenty-five years. Frederick Mathys was serving at Mobile AL when his fiance, 18 year old Sarah Soden, traveled east from Washington to marry him on March 19, 1902. Sarah Mathys returned to her parents' home to give birth. Sometime thereafter, the family was reunited at Fort Brady MI where daughter Katy Beatrice Mathys was born, on January 2, 1906. After Frederick Mathys left the Army, the family settled in Vancouver WA, where younger brother Harry Edson Mathys was born on February 2, 1915. By 1920 family had purchased a home in Vancouver, Washington, and Edwin Mathys attended Vancouver High School in Vancouver, Clark County, Washington.
Edwin Frederick Mathys enlisted in the United States Navy in 1922. For the greater part of his career, he served aboard submarines.
On December 11, 1928 he married an Australian born woman, Eileen Mae Reynolds. This marriage ended in divorce. Edwin Mathys next married Sara Davenport Straughen, a divorcee, in Penns Grove NJ on October 6, 1934. They made their home during the war years at 210 Clinton Avenue, Oaklyn NJ. Edwin Mathys had no children by either marriage.
Chief Machinist Mate Mathys continued to serve aboard submarines, until 1945, when for a reason presently unknown he was given the choice of being on an aircraft carrier or the PE-56 on which he was serving when he died. Chief Machinist's Mate Edwin F. Mathys was killed when the PE-56 , an Eagle-class patrol vessel, was torpedoed by the German submarine U-853 , three miles off Cape Elizabeth ME, on April 23, 1945. The loss of the PE-56 was originally attributed to accident, and it was only determined in the late 1990s that the ship had actually been torpedoed. Chief Mathys was declared missing at that time. After reexamining the evidence regarding the loss of PE-56 , the United States Navy, in June of 2001, amended the regard, and that of all those lost to killed in action. Edwin Frederick Mathys was survived by his wife, parents, and brother Harry. He was also survived by two adopted brothers, Leonard L. and Kenneth J. Mathys, the sons of his deceased sister Katy, who had passed away in 1934.
In November of 2003, I was contacted by Patricia McKee Bauer, the niece of Chief Mathys. After I informed her of the change of status regarding her uncle's death, I advised her that her family should receive the Purple Heart in honor of his service and sacrifice to our country. Ms. Bauer and her family contacted the proper authorities, and on March 25th, 2004 Chief Machinist's Mate Edwin Frederick Mathys was awarded the Purple Heart. The Medal will be presented to the Mathys family within a few weeks of this writing. Phil
Cohen In June of 2018 the wreck of PE-56, which had been detected on sonar, was located by divers off the coast of Maine. After the wreck had been explored and filmed, the discovery was announced to the public in July of 2019. Phil
Cohen
|
|
USS PE-56 Eagle Class Patrol Craft : Laid down at the Ford Motor Co., Rouge Plant, Detroit, Mich., 25 March 1919; Launched, 15 August 1919; Commissioned USS Eagle Boat No. 56, 26 October 1919; Redesignated USS PE-56, 17 July 1920; Torpedoed by the German submarine U-853, 23 April 1945 off Portland, ME. Specifications : Displacement 615 t.; Length 200' 9"; Beam 33' 1"; Draft 8' 6"; Speed 18.3kts; Complement 61; Armament two 4"/50 gun mounts, one 3"/50 gun mount, two .50 cal. machine guns; Propulsion two Bureau Express boilers, Poole geared turbine, one shaft. |
|
For years, the Navy insisted that the USS Eagle had been sunk by a boiler explosion off Maine, but survivors clearly remembered seeing a German U-boat lurking in the area.Paul Lawton's quest to rewrite history began in a Brockton bar on a cold March night in 1998. Warmed by Budweisers and shots of Yukon Jack, he listened as his lifelong friends, two brothers, told the tale of a U.S. warship blown to bits just south of Portland, Maine, late in World War II, and of their father, a 32-year-old seaman who perished in the blast. Vividly, the brothers - Bob and Paul Westerlund - recalled the sadness of the time. And they remembered the Navy explanation: a boiler explosion had split the 200-foot submarine chaser, the USS Eagle PE-56 . A terrible accident, the Navy said, made all the more tragic because it happened on the night of April 23, 1945, just two weeks before Nazi Germany surrendered. But their mother never believed the official version. And so she told her children what survivors had told her -that moments after the explosion, as they were diving into the frigid water, they glimpsed something dark and sinister. It rose to the surface for an instant - a submarine conning tower painted with a mischievous red horse trotting on a yellow shield. Lawton, a lawyer and military historian, is obsessed by submarines. As a child, he spent hours drawing intricate replicas of U-boats and battleships. He has taught courses in U-boat history. He can recite every detail of every battle and loss in the North Atlantic. But he had never heard this story before. Lawton knew that the trotting horse was the insignia of a German U-boat, the U-853, which the records said had sunk just one ship in New England waters - a coal tanker called the Black Point. But the brothers insisted that the U-853 also sank the USS Eagle . Lawton's head was reeling. Forty-nine men died in the Eagle disaster. If they had died in enemy action, they would have been entitled to Purple Hearts. They were entitled to more than being simply written off as victims of a freak accident. Back at his apartment, Lawton pulled out his U-boat "bible," a two-inch-thick book by German historian Jurgen Rohwer. A footnote contained a reference to the USS Eagle and to its probable sinking by U-853 . "I just couldn't believe it," Lawton said. "Why would the Navy say it was a boiler explosion?" He started combing through the archives, calling military historians, and writing letters to various branches of the Navy. He requested the report from the court of inquiry into the sinking, and also wItness statements and deck logs. Sorry, the replies said, but the files were missing and presumed lost. Lawton requested the records of other ships operating in the area at the time, including the destroyer USS Selfridge, which had rescued 13 men from the sinking Eagle . Buried in the military jargon of its deck logs, he found references to sonar detections and to a hunter-killer task force of destroyers and bombers assembled to track down a submarine immediately after the sinking. Inspired by Lawton, the Westerlunds placed a small notice in The Boston Globe, saying they were looking for survivors of the USS Eagle . Two people contacted them immediately. John Breeze, a former naval engineer and USS Eagle survivor vividly, recalled the sinking, the rescue, the dark silhouette of the submarine. Alice Hultgren, a former WAVE remembered taking notes at the hastily convened court of inquiry at a naval dispensary where the survivors were treated. Both were shocked when Lawton told them the official Navy explanation. "Boiler explosion!" Breeze exclaimed over the telephone. "We all--knew it was a sub. How could the Navy deny it?" Hultgren said, "The fellows all said there had been a sub." Their testimony filled 18 pages. Still, Lawton's letters to the Navy continued to be dismissed. "The cause of the sinking has been determined to be the result of a boiler explosion," was the reply he received, over and over. Lawton felt hopeless. And then one morning in October 1999, a package arrived -a 76-page document dated June 1, 1945. It was the court of inquiry report, the formal record that the Navy insisted was missing. Lawton would never know for sure who sent it. He did not need to. In page after page, survivors stated they had seen a submarine. As telling as the eyewitness accounts was the convoluted conclusion. Although the report states that the blast "might have been an enemy mine or an enemy torpedo, " it concludes it "was the result of a boiler explosion, the cause of which could not be determined." To Lawton, it was clear. Top naval officials knew that the Eagle had been sunk by a U-boat, but they could not bring themselves to publicly admit it. Lawton was elated. Surely now the Navy would listen to him. But nothing changed. A year passed. He continued writing letters to everyone he could think of - the Navy, the Secretary of Defense, the White House. And he continued to be told that nothing could be done. Lawton's father, a retired judge and former state representative, became so incensed by the way his son was being ignored that he called his old friend, Congressman Joseph Moakley. Just read the research, he asked him. See what you can do. In late fall 2000, Moakley petitioned the Navy to reopen the Eagle investigation. Although the Navy did agree to Moakley's request, it did forward Lawton's research to the Naval Historical Center. There, it landed on the desk of Bernard Cavalcante, an archivist who had spent 10 years working with German historian Rohwer piecing together a detailed list of all military activity on the Eastern Seaboard. The USS Eagle was on the list, along with its sinking by the U-853 . Cavalcante read Lawton's work in shock, marveling at the research and appalled by the Navy's response. Whatever the justification in wartime, Cavalcante thought, it was time to set the record straight. "Cal made me believe that we could rewrite history," Lawton said. For the next few months, that is what they tried to do. Cavalcante dug up personal notes from his research with Rohwer, as well as declassified that Lawton had not been able to find - records that documented the U-853 operating off the coast of Maine at the time the Eagle went down. Lawton tracked down two more Eagle survivors -Harold Petersen of Rochester, N.Y., and John Scagnelli of Morris Plains, N.J. Like Breeze, both remembered being torpedoed by a submarine. In May 2001, Cavalcante sent a letter to Navy Secretary Gordon England, enclosing a synopsis of Lawton's research and documents backing up the case. And he enclosed a rare recommendation- that the historical record be changed to state that the USS Eagle was sunk as a result of enemy action. The ceremony was simple and solemn, tinged with sadness and with triumph. Aboard a naval museum ship in Quincy on a steamy day last June, the families of the men of the Eagle gathered for a final tribute. The top Navy brass was there, sitting next to widows and sisters and brothers of the men who had died. The Westerlund brothers were there, along with their mother, Phyllis, 87, nervous and full of memories, especially when she met the three survivors -the last men to have seen her husband alive. One by one, the names of the dead were read aloud as family members stepped forward and accepted Purple Hearts. And when the ceremony was over and the speeches were done, three old men wearing caps reading "USS EAGLE" approached Lawton. With tears in their eyes, they handed him a plaque of cherry wood and gold trim. It was engraved with a picture of a warship exploding, and included a brief description of the "forgotten disaster" and one man's quest to set the record straight. It ended with the words. "'We thank you from the bottom of our hearts." |
PORTLAND
PRESS HERALD
49
Lose Lives as Patrol Ship Sinks Off Coast
CRAFT
SPLIT BY BLAST; TWO BODIES FOUND;
The Navy Department Tuesday announced the sinking by explosion of
an Eagle-type patrol vessel, three miles off Cape Elizabeth, and said
that 49 of the ship's crew of 62 either were known dead or "missing
in action." No Maine Victims
None of the 13 survivors was a Maine man, although some had taken
up temporary homes here with their wives and families. One of them,
Lt.(jg) John P. Scagnelli, 25, is a former captain of swimming at New
York university and swam frequently and had competed in a meet the past
winter at the Portland Boys' Club.
Rescue Lasts 17 Minutes
Last of the 13 survivors was picked up about 17 minutes after
personnel aboard a nearby destroyer and lightship had witnessed the
explosion.
Listed as survivors:
Lt. (jg) John P. Scagnelli, 25, USNR, of New
York
City. Breeze, Luttrell and Petersen maintained apartments in Portland, ME, for their families. Breeze lived at 70 Morning Street, Luttrell at 7 Richland Street, South Portland and Petersen at 164 Danforth Street. Sea Was Choppy
The Navy disclosed that the sea was moderate, although choppy,
and visibility was unlimited at the time of the explosion. Didn't Have to Jump
"The magazine, I knew, hadn't gone. From the main deck there
were two exits. I got past a galley on the starboard side and found
myself in water up to my chest. I didn't have to jump overboard,"
he related. Have Varied Opinions
Some survivors reported having seen a
submarine,
others likened the blast to that of a depth charge and some were in
complete disagreement. Doubts Torpedoing
Lockhart, confined to bed by abdominal and hip injuries, injected
himself into the discussion between reporters, survivors and naval
officers to say that "I have seen quite a few ships hit by
torpedoes, but wouldn't say this was one." Blast Shook Ship
The explosion vibrated the entire ship and to Petersen sounded
like a depth charge, he said. |
The Vancouver Columbian FOUR MORE ON CASUALTY ROLL The names of three more Clark county men were contained in today's casualty list from the Office of War Information and one casualty was reported by relatives. In the OWI release are two wounded and one missing. Edwin F. Mathys , Chief MM USN, son of Mr. and Mrs. Fred Mathys, 300 W. Forty-second street, was recently killed when the ship on which he was stationed exploded in the Portland, Maine harbor, it was announced by his relatives today. Mathys enlisted in the navy in 1922, it was reported. News of the explosion declared that of the complement of 65 men, only 14 survivors were listed. |
The Vancouver Columbian BLAST FATAL Killed in a ship explosion in the Portland, Maine, harbor, was Edwin F. Mathys, Chief Machinists Mate He had been in the navy since enlisting in 1922, and was a member of the 65-man crew of which only 14 survived the blast. |
![]() |
Edwin
Mathys' mother, Sarah Mathys standing beside the memorial which has his name on it Clark County
Courthouse Click on Images to Enlarge
|
March 24, 2004 - The Purple Heart Citation |
|
The Columbian - Clark County, Washington - May 3, 2004 |
Sailor's Truth Surfaces Monday,
May 3, 2004
Fifty-nine years after a German U-boat sank his U.S. Navy ship off
the coast of Maine, Vancouver High School graduate Edwin Frederick
Mathys is finally going to get a Purple Heart medal.
"It's just too bad it took so long," said his half-sister, Pat
Bauer, 72, of Vancouver "It's too bad Harry wasn't able to
know," said Edwin's brother, Ken, 76, of Vancouver, who in May will
receive Edwin's medal, given to all troops injured or killed in battle.
Another brother, the late Harry Mathys, served in the Navy for 32 years.
The
Purple Heart was more than a half-century late in arriving because the
government had falsely maintained that Edwin Mathys' ship sank because
its boiler exploded. In fact, the submarine chaser USS Eagle was sunk by
a German submarine. That means Edwin died by hostile fire, not by
accident, and therefore is eligible posthumously for the medal.
Rep.
Brian Baird, D-Vancouver, will present the medal at a date to be set
around Memorial Day, said Baird staff member Matthew Beck.
A
career Navy man with 24 years of service and rank of chief machinist's
mate, Ed Mathys graduated from Vancouver High School in 1920 and
enlisted in 1921.
He died
when German torpedoes sank his ship shortly after noon on April 23,
1945. He was 42 years old. The incident happened just three miles off
Cape Elizabeth, Maine, two weeks before Nazi Germany surrendered.
Until
1999, the U.S. Navy insisted that Mathys' ship, the submarine chaser USS
Eagle, was sunk by a boiler explosion.
Only
after a lengthy investigation and demands for government documents by
Brockton, Mass., lawyer-historian Paul Lawton and two of the 14
survivors did the government finally release a 76-page, June 1, 1945,
document about the incident. It included interviews with the survivors
and proved the ship was sunk by U-853, a German submarine operating
freely in U.S. waters.
"Apparently, the government wanted to keep it covered up,"
Bauer said.
Ken
Mathys, a retired accountant, believes the government was trying to
prevent people from knowing how close the enemy was to the East Coast.
"They were afraid the people in New York City would panic if they
knew Nazi submarines were operating that close to our shores and could
have come right up the Hudson River."
Bauer
never would have found out what really happened to her half-brother 59
years ago if she weren't a genealogist.
While
researching Edwin's life online, she met Phil Cohen of Camden, N.J., who
has created an extensive Web site about veterans in his area. Edwin had
lived there on occasion when he came home from sea.
Cohen
sent her a newspaper story, written last year by Helen O'Neill of the
Associated Press, detailing Lawton's success in convincing the Navy to
tell the real story about the end of the USS Eagle.
Research showed the German U-853 sank Edwin's ship as well as a coal
tanker called the Black Point in New England waters before it was sunk
itself in early May.
Forty-nine men died when the USS Eagle went down; 14 survived. Survivors
John Breeze, of Concord, N.H., Harold Petersen, of Rochester, N.Y., and
John Scagnelli of Morris Plains, N.J., are all still alive and remember
being torpedoed.
The
survivors said the 200-foot ship split in two and sank in a few minutes
after a terrific explosion. Many, apparently including Mathys, were
trapped below deck.
"His bunk was right where the torpedo hit. It just blew it to
bits," Ken Mathys said.
Survivors remained afloat by grasping floating timber, empty oil barrels
and other wreckage.
Edwin
Mathys never had a chance, his siblings said.
"But I'm so happy that we found out the truth of what happened to
him," Bauer said. "It's good to put him to rest."
Dean Baker writes about history, military affairs and agriculture.
|
FOX News - July 21, 2019 |
||
Last US warship sunk by German sub during WWII discovered off Maine Sundday,
July 21, 2019 Divers have discovered the wreck of the last U.S. Navy warship sunk by a German submarine during World War II. Patrol boat USS Eagle PE-56 was located by a private dive team just a few miles off the Maine coast. The discovery ends a 74-year mystery about the ship�s location. The sinking of the USS Eagle PE-56 on April 23, 1945, was originally blamed on a boiler explosion. But the Navy determined in 2001 that it had been sunk by a German submarine. Garry Kozak, a specialist in undersea searches, announced this week that diver Ryan King, of Brentwood, N.H., confirmed in June 2018 that an object Kozak previously discovered on sonar is the vessel 300 feet down. King's team, which later began working with the Smithsonian Channel, extensively explored the ship on the ocean floor, five miles off Cape Elizabeth, Maine. The Naval Historical Center notes that Eagle was towing targets for Navy dive bombers when she was sunk by the German U-853. Her sinking came just two weeks before V-E Day. Only 13 of the 62 crew members survived; they were plucked from the
water by a nearby Navy destroyer.
Underwater video captured by the dive team will be aired in the fall on the Smithsonian Channel's "Hunt for Eagle 56," backing up the story of sailors who said an explosion broke the ship into two pieces, said Kozak. Research undertaken by Paul Lawton, a Massachusetts attorney, naval historian and diver, played a key role in confirming the Eagle�s sinking. "With the deck guns, there was no mistaking it for what it was," he said. The U-853 was later sunk off Block Island on May 6, 1945, by depth charges from USS Atherton and USS Moberly. All hands were lost in the sub�s sinking, which occurred two days before V-E Day, according to the Naval History and Heritage Command. Researchers across the globe are working to locate sites of World War II wrecks. The wreck of an Australian freighter, for example, was recently discovered, as was the wreck of a U.S. B-24 bomber that plunged into the sea off Bermuda in Feb. 1945 And earlier this year, the wreck of World War II aircraft carrier USS Wasp was found in the Coral Sea, and the RV Petrel discovered one of the first Japanese battleships to be sunk by U.S. forces during the war. Imperial Japanese Navy ship Hiei sank on Nov. 14, 1942, in the Solomon Islands. Wasp was also spotted on the seabed by experts from the vessel RV Petrel, which is part of a research organization set up by the late billionaire Paul Allen. Allen, Microsoft's co-founder, died in October 2018 from complications of non-Hodgkin�s lymphoma. His research organization has discovered a host of historic military shipwrecks, such as the wrecks of the USS Helena, the USS Lexington and the USS Juneau. The group�s biggest discovery, however, came in 2017, when Allen and his team found the long-lost wreck of the USS Indianapolis in the Philippine Sea. In a separate project, the wreckage of U.S. B-24 bomber, for example, was found in Papua New Guinea. The plane�s wreck was found in 2018, 74 years after it was shot down during a fierce battle with Japanese forces. Last summer, a team of scientists from the Scripps Institution of Oceanography at the University of California San Diego and the University of Delaware located the missing stern of the destroyer USS Abner Read, which was torn off by a Japanese mine in the remote Aleutian Islands. Also last year, a decades-long mystery about the fate of a ship that disappeared during a World War II rescue mission was finally solved. The wreck of the Empire Wold, a Royal Navy tug, was discovered by coastguards off the coast of Iceland. The ship sank on Nov. 10, 1944, with the loss of her 16 crewmembers. An extremely rare World War II Spitfire fighter plane flown by a pilot who later took part in the "Great Escape" was also recovered from a remote Norwegian mountainside last year. |